by the Living Wage Coalition
Low-wage workers gathered in a town hall meeting in Bayview Hunters Point on June 29 to denounce the growing income inequality in the Bay Area and declare that if their wages did not increase they would be forced to leave their jobs.
Panelists listen as audience member Marilyn Tubao shares her experiences as a homecare provider. Panel members from left are Stacey Curtis, Vernell Hawkins, Kevin Prasad and Arnold Paran. The town hall meeting was held June 29 in the Alex Pitcher Community Room at the Southeast Campus of City College at 1800 Oakdale in Bayview Hunters Point.
“The inequality in wages is ridiculous. The wage gap is getting bigger and, for this part of the workforce, we aren’t getting anywhere. Something has to give,” said Stacey Curtis, a homecare provider who administers vital care to the elderly and infirm so that they can live independently in their homes.
The workers, who came together in the Alex Pitcher Community Room in the Southeast Campus of City College, 1800 Oakdale, were meeting to discuss proposed amendments to the Minimum Compensation Ordinance. The amendments would increase wages for approximately 25,000 low-wage workers, including homecare providers, airport workers and CalWORKs participants, to $15.86 per hour in 2017 and $16.86 per hour by 2018.
The Minimum Compensation Ordinance is different from the Minimum Wage Ordinance and has traditionally been slightly higher. All workers in San Francisco are subject to the Minimum Wage Ordinance, whereas the Minimum Compensation Ordinance applies primarily to the set of workers who are employed by businesses and organizations that have contracts with the City or lease property at the airport.
The event was organized by the San Francisco Living Wage Coalition, the San Francisco Labor Council and Jobs with Justice SF to provide a platform for workers to call upon their district supervisors to support the proposed amendments.
Stacey Curtis, a homecare provider and mother of two, shared her story with the participants in the town hall: “One thing I’ve started to realize is that I’ve sacrificed my family to work – and that should not be. I should not have to work so hard in a given day to where I cannot parent my kids.”
Ms. Curtis went on to lament the fact that with low wages and rising rents “I have been recently priced out of San Francisco … I’ve relocated my family to Richmond to where we live in a two-bedroom with the living room converted into a bedroom for my son because that’s all we can afford.”
“The inequality in wages is ridiculous. The wage gap is getting bigger and, for this part of the workforce, we aren’t getting anywhere. Something has to give,” said Stacey Curtis.
She pointed out that in her experience, besides making it hard for her to support herself, low wages seem to contribute to an attitude in which people do not even seek employment because at minimum wage it isn’t worth the necessary sacrifices. “I see young Black men in my neighborhood who talk to me and say, ‘I’m not going to work for minimum wage.
“’Look at you, what do you have? You don’t have a home, you don’t pay a mortgage, you don’t have a car. Why would I go work for minimum wage when I can sit here on the corner selling drugs?’ So yeah, I think low wages directly relate to crime and poverty, especially in neighborhoods that are already disadvantaged.”
“I think low wages directly relate to crime and poverty, especially in neighborhoods that are already disadvantaged.”
Airport security agents and bag screeners also spoke about the detrimental effects the currently unlivable wages are having on themselves and their jobs. Kevin Prasad, an airport security agent and veteran of the U.S. military, reports that to make ends meet he has needed to take jobs with two different security firms at San Francisco International in order to work enough hours to pay the bills.
As a result, he says that he regularly works 16-hour days and, at the time of the town hall meeting, reported: “I just counted right now, and I’m running on 30 hours straight. I have not slept since 1:30 yesterday.” Essentially, low wages are forcing airport security workers to sacrifice sleep in order to make ends meet, which inevitably means that they cannot be as effective and vigilant as they could be if they were able to work reasonable hours, according to Prasad.
Arnold Paran, an airport bag screener and father of four, was visibly emotional as he shared, “My kids should be going to school and stuff, but the thing is they are helping us to pay our bills. We should be the ones helping our kids, but we are needing our kids to help us.”
Vernell Hawkins, an executive board member of the San Francisco Labor Council and Bayview resident, explained some of the key details of the proposed amendments and urged lawmakers to support them: “There is no better investment than investing in the people who do the hard work taking care of our elderly and disabled, mentoring our youth, counseling families, caring for our homeless and serving our city. It is the right thing to do.”
Hawkins went on to say that the increased wages for homecare providers is personally meaningful for her due to the fantastic care her mother received from a homecare provider for more than eight years after being given only six months to live.
“There is no better investment than investing in the people who do the hard work taking care of our elderly and disabled, mentoring our youth, counseling families, caring for our homeless and serving our city. It is the right thing to do.”
Karl Kramer, campaign co-director for the San Francisco Living Wage Coalition, offered a brief overview of the current economic conditions that make an increase in wages so vital. Kramer cited the fact that the median rent for a studio apartment in Bayview has increased from $2,005 per month in 2013 to $3,755 per month in 2017.
While San Francisco’s minimum wage increased to $14 per hour on July 1, this raise is still insufficient for low-wage earners to keep up with the skyrocketing cost-of-living in the Bay Area. As a result, low-wage workers are being forced to relocate to the Central Valley, which is causing a catastrophic labor shortage and retention problem in vital sections of the job market.
According to Kramer, this retention problem is leading to the loss of experienced workers, which in turn will lead to a decline in the quality of services these workers provide to the residents and visitors of San Francisco. Kramer argued that these issues have to be addressed through laws like the proposed amendments that raise wages in order to help low-wage workers continue to live and participate in the Bay Area job market.
Several audience members who are currently employed in low-wage jobs that would be helped by the proposed amendments shared their stories and emphasized that the current minimum wage was not enough to make ends meet. Workers reported needing to commute long distances from the Central Valley, being forced to make tradeoffs that sacrificed their ability to participate in family life in order to work extra hours to cover living expenses, noticing an issue with high turnover rates at the places they work, and needing their children to take jobs in order to remain in their home.
Several audience members who are currently employed in low-wage jobs that would be helped by the proposed amendments shared their stories and emphasized that the current minimum wage was not enough to make ends meet.
When asked if an increase of $1.86 per hour would help alleviate some of these problems, the panel of assembled workers agreed that an increase wouldn’t make the problems go away but was a necessary first step in the right direction.
The proposed amendments are currently still pending approval from the Budget and Finance Committee before the Board of Supervisors can ultimately vote on them. Bayview’s District Supervisor Malia Cohen is the chair of the committee and has yet to publicly support or oppose the amendments.
To urge Supervisor Cohen to support fair wages for low-wage workers, contact her office at 415-554-7670 or by email at Malia.Cohen@sfgov.org.
For more information on the proposed amendments, call the Living Wage Coalition at 415-863-1225 or email sflivingwage@riseup.net.